Watchdog Investigating DOJ and FBI Coordination with Lawmakers in Jack Smith Prosecution Push
American Oversight is investigating whether the demands to prosecute Jack Smith are part of the effort to keep Smith’s report on Trump’s handling of classified documents hidden.
Today, American Oversight launched an investigation into whether Department of Justice (DOJ) and Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) officials are coordinating with Republican lawmakers in an attempt to discredit former Special Counsel Jack Smith, manufacture a criminal case against him, and justify withholding his findings about President Donald Trump. Through Freedom of Information Act requests, the watchdog seeks to uncover whether officials are selectively sharing records to target Smith while keeping Volume II of his final report on Trump’s handling of classified documents from the public.
The investigation comes amid escalating calls from Trump and Republican lawmakers to prosecute Smith. In January, Trump accused Smith of “large scale perjury” without evidence and demanded his prosecution. During his Senate confirmation hearing in July, then-acting Attorney General Todd Blanche signaled openness to a perjury investigation after Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) urged such action along with possible prosecution. One week later, Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH) submitted a criminal referral that Smith’s attorneys rejected as “meritless.”
At last month’s Senate hearing, Sen. Eric Schmitt (R-MO) used DOJ-provided texts to accuse Smith of perjury, mistakenly claiming he attended an Atlanta Hawks game and suggesting a connection to Trump’s Georgia prosecution. Smith explained that he had attended an Iowa–Maryland women’s basketball game in Maryland. Subsequent reporting revealed that committee staff had warned Schmitt’s team the materials were unverified. Committee Democrats wrote to Sen. Grassley (R-IA) to protest that DOJ/FBI-provided information had not been shared with them in advance of the hearing, and stated that Sen. Schmitt’s questioning “created an embarrassing stain on one of the most important committees in Congress.”
“The DOJ and FBI are supplying records to lawmakers seeking Jack Smith’s prosecution while the Justice Department helps keep his findings about Trump hidden,” said Chioma Chukwu, Executive Director of American Oversight. “Taxpayers funded that investigation. They deserve to know what was uncovered, not have their money used to punish the prosecutor and bury his findings. We’ve seen this pattern too often: Trump’s allies start with an accusation, search for evidence, and keep demanding punishment even when their claims fall apart. Congress should be checking that abuse, not enabling it. The Justice Department and FBI owe the public answers about their role in this effort. We will keep fighting to expose the facts and bring Smith’s findings to light.”
Meanwhile, DOJ has worked to keep Smith’s findings about Trump’s handling of classified documents from the public. Todd Blanche opposed releasing the report during his Senate confirmation hearing, and DOJ later backed Trump’s bid to block disclosure, citing “illegality and impropriety” in Smith’s tenure. That position helped underpin Judge Aileen Cannon’s February 2026 ruling permanently barring disclosure. The effort to suppress Smith’s findings has unfolded alongside attacks on those who investigated Trump: FBI Director Kash Patel defended firing agents involved in the Trump election investigation, accusing them of “weaponization.” American Oversight seeks to uncover whether these attacks and the effort to suppress Smith’s report are connected.
The watchdog’s FOIA requests seek emails and related records between DOJ and FBI officials and the House and Senate Judiciary Committees, including Republican senators’ offices. They also seek text messages between specified officials or their representatives and Rep. Jim Jordan; Sens. Chuck Grassley, Eric Schmitt, Lindsey Graham, and Josh Hawley; and their staff or representatives.
The investigation builds on American Oversight’s fight for the release of the Volume II report. In February 2025, the watchdog sued DOJ under FOIA and, with the Knight First Amendment Institute, sought to intervene in the classified-documents case. Both organizations are appealing Cannon’s denial of intervention and permanent disclosure ban. The Eleventh Circuit scheduled oral argument for Nov. 2, 2026. Trump and his former co-defendants are seeking a delay until at least January 2027 but both plaintiff organizations oppose that request.